Build Your Own 12-Pack
Build Your Own 12-Pack
Build Your Own 12-Pack
Build Your Own 12-Pack
Build Your Own 12-Pack
Build Your Own 12-Pack
Build Your Own 12-Pack
Build Your Own 12-Pack
Build Your Own 12-Pack
Build Your Own 12-Pack
The Frosted Sheep

Build Your Own 12-Pack

$48.00 USD
Ships Nationwide · Order by Mon 5pm ET

The perfect gift for a family, a team, or anyone who deserves a dozen. Build a box of 12 scratch-made cookies, hand-picked by you and baked fresh in our Canton bake shop.

Choose all of their favorites, or mix and match for a little of everything. Add a gift message, and we'll tuck it inside, then ship it straight to their door.

It's the same thoughtfully sourced ingredients and made-from-scratch recipes we bake every day at The Frosted Sheep, packed with care for the trip.

Pick your flavors. Add a note. We'll bake and ship it.

12-Count: Choose exactly 12 cookies from the flavors below.

How shipping works: We bake and ship once a week. Orders placed by Monday at 5pm ET ship that Tuesday. Orders placed after the cutoff ship the following Tuesday.

Choosing a shipping option: For the freshest cookies, choose Next Day Air Saver or 2nd Day Air. Ground shipping is available, but we only recommend it for deliveries within Connecticut.

Each order ships to one address. Want cookies for pickup instead? Place a pre-order and choose your pickup time.

Our products are made in a kitchen that handles common allergens. Ingredients and allergens vary by flavor.
Meet the Flavors

Brown Butter Chocolate Chip
Nutty brown butter, premium chocolate, crisp golden edges, and a soft, chewy center. Rich, buttery, and deeply chocolatey.

Ginger Molasses
Deep molasses, crystallized ginger, cinnamon, and cloves with a sparkling sugar crust. Warm, chewy, and boldly spiced.

Snickerdoodle
Buttery and soft with cinnamon sugar, lightly crisp edges, and a signature crackly finish. Warm, nostalgic, and perfectly spiced.

Lemon White Chocolate Chip
Bright, tart lemon balanced by creamy white chocolate and a delicate lemon drizzle. Fresh, buttery, and just sweet enough.

Oatmeal Raisin
Hearty oats, plump organic raisins, warm spice, and a touch of local honey. Soft, chewy, and wonderfully comforting.

Butterscotch Chip
Nutty brown butter and creamy Guittard butterscotch chips with notes of caramel and toasted sugar. Rich, chewy, and indulgent.

Glazed Sugar
Buttery sugar cookie infused with fragrant Tahitian vanilla and finished with a silky vanilla glaze. Soft, tender, and delicately sweet.
Shipping & Delivery

Orders are freshly baked and ship via UPS on Tuesdays. Available services and rates are calculated at checkout based on the destination and package details. Delivery timing begins once your order ships and may be affected by holidays, weather, or carrier delays.
Refunds & Order Issues

Because our cookies are freshly baked and perishable, we are unable to accept returns. If your order arrives damaged, incorrect, or in unsatisfactory condition, please contact us promptly with your order number and photos so we can help make it right.

View our Refund Policy
Have a question or special request?

We’d love to hear from you!

Location: The Frosted Sheep Bake Shop
220 Albany Turnpike
Canton Village Shopping Center
Building 5, Rear Unit
Canton, CT 06019

Phone: (959) 866-3074

Email: info@frostedsheep.com
Loading ...

Frequently Asked Questions

Everything you need to know about building, shipping, and enjoying your cookie box.
How does the Build Your Own Cookie Box work?

Choose a 6-count or 12-count box, then select exactly that number of cookies from the available flavors. Mix and match however you’d like.
Can I choose more than one of the same flavor?

Absolutely. Fill your box with a variety of flavors or stock up on your favorites. The mix is entirely up to you.
Which cookie flavors are available?

Available flavors are shown when building your box. Selection may change as seasonal and limited-edition cookies come and go.
Can I order a Build Your Own Cookie Box for pickup?

No. Build Your Own Cookie Boxes are available for shipping only and cannot be ordered for pickup at our Canton bake shop. 
Are the cookies baked fresh for shipping?

Yes, your cookies are baked fresh before being carefully packed and shipped.
Can I send a cookie box as a gift?

Yes, please do! Ship your box directly to the recipient by entering their address as the shipping address at checkout.
Do the cookies contain allergens?

Ingredients and allergens vary by flavor, and our products are made in a kitchen that handles common allergens. Please review the individual flavor information carefully before ordering.
How are the cookies packaged for shipping?

Each cookie is individually wrapped to help preserve freshness, then carefully packed in your Frosted Sheep cookie box to protect the cookies during their journey to you.
How should I store my cookies once they arrive?

For the best experience, keep your cookies tightly wrapped or in an airtight container at room temperature. For longer storage, cookies can be frozen and thawed at room temperature when you’re ready to enjoy them.